Archive for the ‘Immigration Policy’ Category

Open Borders

August 12, 2014 Leave a comment

I have regularly seen statements in the press suggesting that many writers in the media think that we should have open borders, an immigration policy that literally allows anyone to enter the U.S. Indeed there are people who correctly point out that the U.S. had open borders in the past and they use this fact to argue that this evidence implies that we should do this now. The fact that we did this in the past is irrelevant for the following reasons.

In the nineteenth century, my ancestors came to the U.S. knowing that they would need to fend for themselves once they got here. There was no welfare that they would get and the state was not going to provide health care without requiring payment. Many immigrants did not attend public schools or did so for only a short time. In short, coming to the U.S. meant that the individual was on his or her own to survive once in the U.S. Compare that to the situation now.

Illegal aliens can now get health care, school access, food stamps, and other benefits once they are in the U.S. How does the existence of these subsidies affect the characteristics of the the potential immigrants to the U.S.?  Clearly we will attract some people willing to get on the public dole once they are in the U.S. Those people will ultimately draw public resources, raising government deficits or requiring increases in marginal tax rates. The latter reduce Potential GDP. So the existence of the welfare state makes past immigration policies irrelevant to what would happen now if the U.S. had open borders. More generally, why do we want people to come here who only have an interest in getting on the government dole?

Once again, policy design requires thinking about economic incentives. Open borders is a bad idea because of the incentives that it creates.


Categories: Immigration Policy

Charging Admission into the U.S.

March 4, 2013 3 comments

Gary Becker and Edward Lazear, two distinguished economists, recently published an article advocating that the U.S. begin charging an admission price to immigrants into the U.S. Upon reading their piece, I couldn’t help but be amused by imagining how many non-economists would respond to such a proposal. I can just see the reaction. ¬†How absurd to charge admission! But what do you expect. This is the same crowd that thinks we should charge for human organs!

Before you think their idea to be crazy, I urge everyone to read the article. It is natural for economists to think of a market-based solution to a policy problem. Consider the benefits to the program that they list but also ask yourself this question. Would their program be worse than anything dreamed up by the government?

Categories: Immigration Policy
Economics One

A blog by John B. Taylor

The Grumpy Economist

One economist's views on economic policy.

The Blog

The latest news on and the WordPress community.

%d bloggers like this: